UnitedHealth Slashes 2025 Earnings Forecast on Rising Medical Costs

UnitedHealth Group has stunned Wall Street with a deep cut to its 2025 profit forecast, blaming persistent and rising medical costs. The nation’s largest insurer now expects far slimmer earnings next year, underscoring mounting pressures across the entire health insurance sector.

Shares dropped sharply after the announcement, as investors absorbed news that UnitedHealth’s woes could signal broader trouble for the industry.

Forecast Falls Well Short of Expectations

UnitedHealth’s new guidance projects 2025 adjusted earnings of at least $16 per share, coupled with revenue between $445.5 billion and $448 billion. That’s a significant miss versus Wall Street’s upbeat estimates, which had anticipated $20.91 per share in earnings and even higher revenue figures.

Did you know?
UnitedHealth’s 2024 was marred not only by soaring costs but also by the unprecedented murder of its CEO, a rare event in corporate America.

Medical Costs Outrace Premiums

Key to the downgrade: A surge in healthcare spending, particularly in its Medicare Advantage plans, is battering UnitedHealth's insurance unit. The medical care ratio, a metric measuring payouts versus premiums, is expected to hit 89-89.5% in 2025, up from 85.1% just a year earlier. Rising surgeries and deferred care since the pandemic are playing a major role.

Medicare Funding and DOJ Scrutiny

Medicare funding cuts are squeezing margins even further, making it harder for UnitedHealth to recoup rising costs through premium hikes. Compounding investor anxiety, the company is now cooperating with a Department of Justice investigation into its Medicare billing, a shadow that may linger over its 2025 outlook.

ALSO READ | When your teen’s BFF is a bot, what could go wrong?

Business Lines: Optum Rises, But Not Enough

Despite the bleak forecast, UnitedHealth posted a 17% jump in revenue from its insurance arm in the most recent quarter, as well as a nearly 19% spike for its pharmacy benefit manager, Optum Rx. However, Optum Health’s revenue slipped 7% year-over-year, reflecting operational challenges and increased scrutiny.

New Leadership Faces Daunting Turnaround

It’s the first earnings report under new CEO Stephen Hemsley, who steps in after a year of leadership turmoil and heavy public scrutiny. The company’s 2024 challenges included the high-profile departure and tragic murder of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO, plus a damaging cyberattack. With shares down more than 44% year-to-date, Hemsley is under pressure to restore confidence and earnings momentum.

Industry-Wide Warning

Analysts see UnitedHealth’s grim update as a bellwether for the sector, suggesting that other major insurers may face similar cost headwinds in 2025. As seniors return for delayed surgeries and health systems struggle to control expenses, the health insurance industry braces for a tougher road ahead.

Despite the outlook, UnitedHealth insists that their fundamentals and potential for growth remain intact. “While we face challenges across our lines of business, we believe we can resolve these issues and recapture our earnings growth potential while ensuring people have access to high-quality, affordable health care,” said UnitedHealthcare CEO Tim Noel.

UnitedHealth’s next steps and the industry’s response will set the tone for insurers and investors amid a fast-changing healthcare landscape.